Category Archives: View

View 737 Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Freedom is not free. Free men are not equal. Equal men are not free.

Harry Harrison, RIP. There will be many obituaries, and he will be missed. We were once fairly close friends, which is odd given our political differences were vast and probably irreconcilable, but I haven’t seen him for years. When I was in NYC promoting Lucifer’s Hammer, Harry was in town staying at the Player’s Club on Grammercy Park, and invited me to lunch with him there. Those were the only times I’ve ever been in there, an elegant place. Of course Harry then invited me to play pool with him. For money. At which he was far better than I would ever be. Which meant that I actually paid for the lunch. But it was worth it.

I liked Harry. Haven’t seen him in years but I will miss him. Harry and Joan used to get to Los Angeles more often in the old days after they made Soylent Green out of Make Room! Make Room!

Way back when not long after I was President of Science Fiction Writers of America Cal Tech had a three day festival on science fiction and literature. Harry and I were on a panel with Sir Fred Hoyle, and, I think Richard Feynman although I may be mistaken in that memory. It was in a big well shaped lecture hall with a slate top table for speakers and high motorized blackboards behind us. Just after the introductions were done one of the blackboards began to rise, revealing the blackboard behind it, where someone had chalked in bold letters GET SCIENCE FICTION OUT OF THE CLASSROOM AND BACK IN THE GUTTER WHERE IT BELONGS. Of course Harry had arranged that.

I had thought to write some observations about the election, and perhaps I will later, but mostly it’s still the Silly Season.

Thanks to Roberta we got out for a walk this morning before it became too hot. Sable was happy to get home and find a cool place to lie down. This is no weather for a snow dog, but we’re all well, if a bit under this weather.

And I note in today’s LA Times that of 29 new TV Series opening this Fall, precisely 2 of them will be filmed in Los Angeles. It used to be that 90% of television one-hour shows were filmed here, but Los Angeles city, Los Angeles County, and the State of California decided to raise taxes and raise taxes, and, oh, by the way, we’re raising taxes, so that even New York City – New York City! – is a more attractive environment for filming big name TV series than Hollywood. Which means that the huge set crews, makeup people, caterers, retired policemen, gaffers and grips, and of course writers won’t be working here any longer. All I can tell my neighbors, many of whom are in what we used to call The Industry, is cheer up, things can be worse. I don’t add that they probably will be. It’s grim out there, and I live in Studio City which was less affected by the crash than a lot of the city.

And meanwhile , the radio tells me that a hearse driver was found dead at the wheel not far from the Beverly Hills Hotel. Inside there was a casket complete with body. No other details released. We still live in Los Angeles.

Fish and wildlife bullets

Dr. Pournelle:

I have little experience with firearms, but the webpage referred to jacketed hollow point bullets. Isn’t that more bullet than necessary even for self defense?

jomath

I haven’t thought about such matters in years. When I was involved in such matters I recommended wad cutters as being effective while less danger to neighbors, for the same reasons I recommended #4 birdshot as the default for a home defense shotgun. But that was long ago. I can understand that game wardens – I’d presume that’s why Fish and Wildlife needs ammunition – may need to be armed in these times, but I would think only for self defense: I am still in favor of having most federal arrests being made in concert with the local sheriff as they should have been in Waco. If game wardens need a SWAT team they should call on the Marshals or preferabl9y the local authorities. 

View 737 Tuesday, August 14, 2012

The heat wave continues. My office telephone is acting up. I managed to replace a feed line and it is now more or less working properly, but one gets overheated doing anything in this weather. Ah well. Sable finds a cool part of the floor to lie on, and probably wonders why we aren’t taking her for walks. Actually, it’s very nice out at 6AM. We’ll have to think about that.

Incorrect Information: NWS Not Buying Ammo

Dr. Pournelle,

I read with dismay the posting you made today about the National Weather Service buying ammo, primarily because it’s not true and a couple of minutes of research would have shown this. The solicitation for ammo at the link https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&id=bfd95987a1ad9a6dfb22bca4a19150cb&tab=core&tabmode=list& is filled with errors. There is no such thing as "DOC NOAA National Weather Service – Western Acquisition Division – Boulder". The Department of Commerce has a Western Acquisition Division in Boulder. Further reading of the solicitation clearly indicates that every round of ammo is destined for the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), which is part of NOAA. Why the NMFS needs the ammo I cannot say.

Obviously the individual preparing the solicitation used some previous solicitation as a boiler-plate and didn’t completely excise the no longer relevant data.

I agree with your sentiments that the Federal government should be smaller than it is, but with posts like this, you make yourself sound more anarchist than rational. Perhaps I’m being unfair to you. Maybe Mr. Martin is a trusted correspondent of yours so you felt little need to trust but verify. This touched a sore spot with me because I for one think the Weather Service is actually good value for the tax dollars spent but in the rush to universally condemn everything the Federal government does (a theme that is more and more prevalent in your postings), I’m afraid the legitimate things the Feds do will not get the protection they deserve.

Jay Smith

No, I thought the story was screwy, and possibly satirical, but I saw no great harm in posting it: the horror is that it might be true, just as my fanciful tale of TSA SWAT teams appearing at your house to arrest you for putting out too much CO2 might be thought possible with just a bit of belief suspension. When a guitar company is raided by a guns drawn team of federal agents because it might have illegally imported wood, what is actually impossible? Weather bureau bureaucrats shooting fish seems unlikely, but is it impossible? Presumably someone is going to fire those cartridges.

We still have bunny inspectors, and armed agents still raid vitamin companies. After all, we would have thought it impossible that the Federal Government would arrange for assault weapons and ammunition to be fast and furiously delivered to Mexican drug cartels, or at least that there would have been some kind of adult supervision by constitutionally responsible officers – or that once this came to light the constitutionally responsible officers would be concerned – or something. Yet the response of the constitutional officers seems to be defiance of the Congress. It’s all a puzzlement.

In any event, I haven’t lost my mind, and I don’t think I have deceived anyone. One of the advantages of being me is that if I do post a bit of questionable mail, someone will tell me. Quickly. Thanks. Readers may now be warned.

As to the less whimsical part of your letter, of course the Federal Government does some things well, and some are quite necessary. Adam Smith noted that there are great project whose benefit to any one person is small but which have enormous benefits to all, and those are a proper concern of government. The Framers thought so. They had in mind roads and canals, but I doubt that Franklin would have objected to government research laboratories. I am hardly an anarchist.

On the other hand, transparency is generally desirable.

And aha:

: NMFS Office of Law Enforcement

Dear Jerry,

The National Marine Fisheries Services has an office of law enforcement that deals with poachers, illegal imports of seafood and other laws that the agency is charged with enforcing.

http://www.nmfs.noaa.gov/ole/

Best regards,

Bob Kawaratani

Which makes a fair amount of sense, although I continue to worry about the multiplication of law enforcement agencies. Why can’t the US Marshals take care of such matters? I can understand having an enforcement counsel to coordinate with the Marshals, or the Revenoors, or whatever, but I am not really sure that the Marine Fisheries Service needs armed game wardens. Perhaps so. It is a dangerous world out there and even the game wardens may now need to be armed although they certainly were not when they inspected fishing licenses from those fishing in federal waters (TVA created lakes) on the Tennessee River when I was a kid.  I had a shotgun but the warden was unarmed, and neither of us was afraid of the other. But that was a different world in a different time. Still, both for economic and liberty reasons, perhaps some rethinking of enforcement of federal regulations is in order. Did we learn nothing from Waco?  But now I am rambling.

Recently a US Marshal (prisoner escort) was allowed through TSA with his weapon and ammunition, but they had to confiscate his bottle of cologne which was too large to take on an airplane. At least that’s the story he tells on the air. Of course the teller may not really be a US Marshall, or he may be making up the story, or – but does anyone believe it is impossible?

Firefox has started another of its rounds of updates, worries, compatibility checks, and general annoyances. Coupled with Adobe’s insistence on updates when and how it feels like. And were I not conscientiously complying with the frantic please for energy conservation by trying to operate without air conditioning I would probably not notice. It’s the dog days of the silly season.

View 737 Monday, August 13, 2012

We’re home and all’s well, if you can call a heat wave ‘well’. It’s about 100 outside the house, and the municipal power people are begging us to be sparing with the air conditioning because there’s a chance of power shortages. Given what we pay the various public service union people in Los Angeles you’d think they’d have seen this coming and come up with a way to do something about it, but I don’t know what that is. On the other hand I don’t get paid what the public service people get paid.

I note that we are moving toward feudalism. In feudal times people paid what they had to to the local knights, who undertook to defend them from the barbarians. In those times the barbarians came from outside the city gates, although I expect they had some inside also. In our case we are raising cultures of barbarians, some in the cities, some in California’s Central Valley. So we pay $150,000 to $300,000 a year with full pensions after 20 years to police officers, the new Blue Knights. Knighthood was never hereditary although the chance to become a knight was much higher for the children of knights than for the peasantry, and over time the social classes became something like a caste system. Could we be going that way in the US?

In any event, we are home, and the election proceeds. Those who think that the best chance for America lies in fooling or deceiving the electorate believe that the choice of Ryan was a drastic mistake, because it will make it clear that this will be a crucial election, responsibility vs. entitlement. My own view is that if the country chooses the road to serfdom we need to rethink the whole concept of Constitutional government – which, by the way, will be inevitable in any event. Think about the difficulty of getting Germans to work 40 hour weeks so that Greek civil servants can have 30 hour weeks with 13 week vacations, and apply that to the US, substituting whomever you choose for Greek civil servants and hard working Germans. The point is that eventually those who produce the wealth will demand a say in its distribution, and those who distribute will find themselves running short of something to distribute, and those who contribute nothing to the economy but their progeny will find that everyone has decided the services of the proletariat are overvalued. Or so things have always been. Perhaps it will be different in these United States.

Or, perhaps, we will turn back from the road to serfdom and quite deliberately choose liberty and responsibility. It will be interesting to see. But I do recall the elections of 2010.

Government is too big. Hope and Change were chosen over what was thought to be the path by which government got too big, and the result was a doubling of the debt while unemployment remained high. Hope and Change didn’t work, and all we are offered is more of what doubled the debt.

OMG!

We all know what CNN’s take was going to be no matter who Romney picked because it’s CNN’s daily job to sew fear and panic about Republican actions.

So isn’t it absolutely absurd for Frum to pretend Romney wasn’t going to be tied to House Republicans by the media — starting with CNN? The only real question is whether Ryan helps Romney more than any of the alternatives.

–Mike

http://www.cnn.com/2012/08/13/opinion/frum-romney-ryan/index.html?hpt=hp_t1

Opinion: By picking Paul Ryan as his running mate, Mitt Romney is tying himself to House Republicans, to the benefit of the Obama campaign, David Frum says.

I am no longer surprised by anything the egregious Frum says. Thanks.

Adding Ryan to the ticket does little for Romney among various cliques and factions, but that wasn’t the point. Justice Roberts has said that the Supreme Court can hold out against the will of the legislative and executive branches for only so long, and we are at the edge now. Romney’s choice of Ryan will make it clear what this election means. One way or another.

View 737 Sunday, August 12, 2012

I spent part of the afternoon watching the Ryan and Romney show, and I was impressed. They play off each other very well. Clearly each respects the other, and they are in essential agreement.

Regarding foreign policy: an old friend reminds me that most of Ryan’s votes on foreign policy have been in support of the Republican establishment, and hardly in line with my suggestions of speaking softly while carrying a large cudgel. That of course is both true and expected. Ryan is Chairman of the Budget Committee. A powerful committee, and one that has no formal connection to foreign policy although of course at bottom financial control is power over almost anything. But to get that kind of committee chairmanship requires that you get along with other committee chairmen, and that usually means supporting their policies. You can call that unfortunate, but it is the essence of liberal democracy and pretty well has been for a long time. And yes going along to get along can be a terrible thing, and once in a while someone has to upset that apple cart. As Newt did.

But I have some reason to believe that both Romney and Ryan are closer to my views of American foreign policy – we are friends of liberty everywhere but guardians only of our own, and if you would have peace be prepared for war – than to the neoconservative imperialisms. And whatever their foreign policy views they are likely to be superior to what we are doing now. There isn’t a good simple description of our current foreign policy, which seems to be based on finger wagging, stating that something is unacceptable while clearly accepting it, telling everyone what they ought to be doing without paying much attention to what they are doing, and in generally promoting democracy by wishing for it without quite realizing what it would mean if implemented. Perhaps I am overly harsh, but I don’t think so.

There is a crisis in Turkey, another in Egypt, and others throughout the Middle East. Assad has clearly been told that he is unacceptable, meaning that nothing he can do will assure that he or any of his family will survive. He may as well fight on. Qadaffi found that out: he acceded to nearly every demand the US placed on him, but he found there is no forgiveness. Mubarak made the same discovery. Being a friend of the United States does not assure you of life even in exile. Sun Tzu tells us we must build golden bridges for our enemies, but Clinton, Bush II, and Obama blew up even the most rickety bridges that our friends and suitors might try to retreat over. Whatever will happen in Egypt now is beyond our control. We can only trust in Hope and Change, and hope that the change will — but then we run out of words because we don’t know what to hope for. As the Israelis must know by now. I am sure Netanyahu learned well when on his last visit he was dismissed from the White House by way of a tour of the trash piles.

In Iraq our only friends are the Kurds, who have built a Kurdish state on the Turkish border. Since about the only thing that Iran and Turkey agree on is that there must not be a Kurdish sanctuary for Kurdish rebels on their borders, this brings about interesting possibilities for realignments. Turkey at one time was very nearly an ally of Israel. Now all that has changed, as the successors of Mustapha Kemal are purged from the Turkish government – and the successors of Mubarak are dismissed from control of the Egyptian Mamelukes.

I have no certainties about US Middle East policies except this one: almost any consistent policy is probably better than what we have been doing. We invaded Iraq without any clear goals, sent in the most incompetent proconsul since Roman times, then staggered to a conclusion that leaves us nearly broke without obvious benefits from a pair of costly wars that could have been handled by punitive expeditions. Indeed, the Afghan War was settled by a few special forces. The Taliban was taught in no uncertain terms not to harbor enemies of the United States. What more did we need? But we had to build democracy in a land that doesn’t want it. But enough rambling. I have good reason to believe that a Romney/Ryan administration will not put us through military adventures. They can’t afford to, and Ryan knows that.

The election won’t be fought on foreign policy issues anyway. Both Romney and Ryan have said it flat out: this is a referendum on which way America will go, further down the road to entitlement until ruin, or back toward liberty and responsibility. There will be talk about jobs and prosperity, and most of us who believe in freedom will argue that liberty is a better path to prosperity than regulation and central planning – but even if it were not, is not liberty important in its own right?

We are down at the beach house for the weekend. For the story of how we acquired a beach house, and last year’s communications problems, see http://www.chaosmanorreviews.com/oa/2011/20110711_col.php.

When you are on the road nowadays you are seldom far from some kind of Wifi connection. Hotels, airport waiting rooms and particularly airline lounge clubs, coffee shops – there are Wifi networks everywhere, but as luck would have it, there isn’t one anywhere near our beach condo. I used to have cable modem, but for good and sufficient reasons that’s not an option right now. Last year I solved the problem using the AT&T USB Connect 900, which I bought in the local AT&T store. The device looks like a large thumb drive, and it connects to a USB port, where it functions sort of like a cell phone. In fact, it really is a 3G cellphone, and actually has a cell phone number.

When you get the Connect 900 you choose a data plan. You can choose to pay a monthly rate, but since you aren’t likely to use this when you have another option, that probably doesn’t make sense for most people. One option is a $50 prepayment. That’s good for one month or 5 GB of data, whichever gets used up first. After that, the Connect 900 will still connect to AT&T, and it will offer you the opportunity to buy more time or more gigabytes. I know that works because I have done it.

This time it didn’t work. I plugged in the Connect 900, it called home and connected to AT&T, then opened my browser, and a friendly message told me hello, please log in and buy some more time. AT&T even told me my log in name. It only wanted my password. That should have been all right. I had that written down in my log book, and for that matter the ThinkPad remembered the password because I had told it to, possibly foolish thing to do, and I won’t be doing it any more. The only problem is that while I remembered my password, and my computer remembered my password, AT&T didn’t. It kept telling me to log in. I cursed a bit, and got by with a dialup connection for a day or so, but it wasn’t much fun. When I first started doing Internet stuff including blogging – I can make a reasonable argument to having been the first blogger, although I didn’t call it that because I thing the word blog is ugly – we were almost all on dialup unless we were on an academic or government campus that had backbone connections, and we were all careful to keep our web sites simple and easy to use because there weren’t any high speed connections when we were on the road. Those were the days of hacking into a hotel’s telephone system just to get dialup. But nowadays almost everyone has high bandwidth, and web sites often make a dozen link calls, and bring in fancy graphics, and some web sites are nearly impossible for people on dialup, and I decided to go get my Connect 900 activated. The AT&T store is only a couple of miles away from my Mission Beach condo.

Traffic was horrible. Mission Beach is a busy place and this was one of its busiest weekends, miles of tourists in cars, bicycles, tourist busses, golf carts, roller blades, and nearly every conceivable means of locomotion. It took half an hour to get the two miles to the AT&T store, where I was pleasantly surprised to find that there were five uniformed employees and no customers.

I hauled out the ThinkPad and explained my problem to one of the clerks. I showed him that the Connect 900 was working fine, and was in fact able to connect to AT&T, but AT&T didn’t believe my password, and could he do something about that. Alas, he said, he didn’t think so. He’d never encountered that problem before. However, he’d try. First thing was to get my ThinkPad on the store’s wireless net. That turned out to be harder than it ought to be, because Windows 7 has a wireless management system, and the ThinkPad has a Lenovo wireless management system, and they hate each other, so you have to be familiar with both so you can keep one from interfering with the other, and my AT&T clerk cursed Windows because he was an Apple man. But eventually we go connected to the local Wifi net, and after a while we discovered what the problem was: AT&T remembered that I had an account, but I hadn’t used it in 180 days (or perhaps longer) – so AT&T cancelled the account. Alas, though, my Connect 900 couldn’t start a new account because it was still associated with the old one.

The clerk ingeniously solved the problem by removing the sim card from the Connect 900 and putting in a new one. I told you it was really a cellphone. With a new sim card AT&T saw it as a new phone, and asked me to tell it my name, address, phone number, email number, secret words, the name of my neighbor’s cat, and so forth, created a new account, let me log in to it, and now was ready to charge my American Express card for prepayment of a block of time and gigabytes. There wasn’t any charge for the new sim card.

After which everything worked just fine. The AT&T 3G system works quite well. It’s not as fast as modern Wifi, but the slowness is lagging response time rather than throughput. And of course Wifi can get overloaded easily. All in all, having a working 3G connection system can be a useful backup for any road warrior. The only caution is that you will have to buy a day’s time twice a year else AT&T will close you out and you’ll have to go to an AT&T store to get a new sim card so you can fool AT&T into thinking you have bought a new Connect 900. It works with Apple and Linux systems as well as Windows. Recommended for road warriors who want to be sure of having a connection wherever you have 3G bars.

My beach house writing establishment: ThinkPad connected to an ancient but very good ViewSonic monitor, Microsoft wireless keyboard and mouse, and other stuff. I do a lot of work down here, and Niven and I have done two novels here. When we started the monitor was older and the first computer I brought down here was a desktop with a 19” bottle monitor.

There is a lot of good mail, and I had intended a big mailbag for tonight, but it’s late, I am tired, and we will probably go home tomorrow, so it will have to wait. I’ll get there. I’ve got some of my energy back.

and we’re home